Monday, April 25, 2011

Bottled Water Vs. Tap Water At Harwood Union

Bottled Water Vs. Tap Water
Carrie Johnson
How can eliminating the consumption of bottled water here at Harwood save both energy and money?
          Do you drink bottled water? If you do, what are your reasonings? Is it because you think it’s healthier or tastes better? Or because the label or brand intrigues you? Or is it because these bottled water companies put so much time and effort into advertising that convinced you to believe that you need bottled water? Whatever your reason is, rethink it. Here at Harwood we are given many different bottled water sources. Whether it’s a vending machine, lunch line, or in the cafe, we have access to bottled water at any time of the day. But has anyone ever stopped to think what would happen if we were to get rid of bottled water? Bottled water is one of the most wasteful things in our society today, and it’s up to you, bottled water drinkers to stop it.
          The way I think of it, we should be giving up bottled water. If not entirely, then at least minimizing it. There are times when you have no other choice, you’re thirsty and all there is is bottled water, but I’m hoping to help by making sure there is always another alternative, and to persuade you to use that alternative. I have five great reasons for you about why you should give up bottled water. 
          First, the plastic bottled water bottles are made from a plastic (most being polyethylene terephthalate), that is not meant for multiple uses. They are fine for single uses, but reusing them can lead to bacterial growth and leaching of dangerous chemicals. Not to mention the amount of energy that is put into manufacturing the plastics, fabricating the plastic into bottles, processing the water, filling and sealing the bottles, transporting the bottles, and chilling the bottles for use. Between 5.6 and 10.2 million joules of energy is required per liter of water. A typical bottled water size is about 0.5 liters. That’s up to 2,000 times the energy it takes to produce tap water, which also only costs 0.005 joules per liter. Thats a lot of wasted energy that is just being thrown in the land fills that can easily be turned around by using tap water. 
          Secondly, bottled water is full of oil. More than 17 millions barrels of oil is required to make bottled water annually. Thats enough to fuel hundreds of thousands of cars for a year. In other words, the whole energy cost of a lifecycle of a bottle of water is about equivalent to filling each bottle a quarter with oil. 
          Third, bottled water is expensive. Why spend all that money on something you have for free all around you? Drinking the recommended daily amount of water costs about $1,400 a year. Drinking the same amount of tap water costs about 49 cents annually.
          Fourth, tap water is fine to drink. Despite what most people have come to believe, over 90% of water systems meet the EPA’s (Environmental Protections Agency) standards for tap water quality. If your water system isn’t drinkable, its easier, cheaper, and more energy efficient to get it filtered and cleaned.
          Lastly, at least 40 percent of bottled water comes from some tap somewhere in the world anyway. Many bottled water companies fill their bottles with a tap, so you’re actually being tricked into paying for just the bottle. Bottled water companies also try to tick you into thinking their water is better than it is. You have to read the fine print to find the truth. For example, Everst Water is not from Mount Everest, it’s from Corpus Christi, Texas. Glacier Clear Water is not from a glacier, it’s tap water from Greenville Tennessee. Dasani and Aquafina are also just sources of tap water from all around the country. One of Aquafina’s is the Detroit River! The water might as well have come from your tap in the first place.
         In New York City, a test was made to discover what people think of bottled water and tap water. Before this test was done, samples of Evian, Aquafina, Poland Springs, Iceland Spring (which actually comes from Iceland), American Fare (a discount brand from Kmart), and a sample from a drinking fountain in the middle of NYC were sent to the University of New Hampshire to test for bacteria that makes you sick, like e. coli. The test results showed that there was no different between the tap water and the bottled waters that were evaluated. This isn’t the first test that has been done like this, and they have all come out with the same result. Tap water is just as good for you as bottled waters that cost 500 times more. For the test of the people from NYC, each person was given a cup of each type of water, and asked to rate them either bad, average, or great. "I can definitely taste the difference between like a Fiji water and an Evian and a Poland Spring," one woman said. "I think tap water kind of tastes like sewer," said another. In the end, the results showed that the Kmart brand, American Fare, won. Aquafina came in second, Iceland Spring tied with tap water for third place. Fifth place went to Poland Spring. In last place, by a landslide, was the fanciest, most expensive, Evian. Almost half the testers even referred to it as bad. "It tasted like toilet water," one man said.
         If that isn’t enough to convince you to give up tap water, then I don’t know what will. By reducing the use of bottled water here at Harwood we can save money, energy, and waste. Instead of putting time, money and energy in getting bottled water for our school, we could be putting time into cleaning the tap water we have here in our water fountains. The water is said to be clean as it is, but I’ll admit I’m one of the doubters. Harwood water just doesn’t look, taste, or ever smell right. All that is most likely just a fault in the pipes.Technically, it’s still fine to drink, but I’d rather drink it if it were also aesthetically pleasing.  We could take time to get the pipes cleaned up so our water isn’t discolored or off-tasting. In the long run, using our water fountains and bringing reusable water bottles from home will really save our school money, and energy that we could be putting towards something else. Maybe even selling or giving out reusable water bottles at our front desk or cafeteria could be a good alternative. That way if students don’t own or remember to bring their reusable bottle to school, they always have access to a good, clean one.
         I’ve come to the conclusion is my research that one of the greatest ways I can save myself money, and the economy energy, is to use those reusable water bottles I have for sports when I’m wanting some water. I bet I can get just about everyone to agree with me on this one, everyone loves a good opportunity to save money. Why not start with saving it on water? A substance that is constantly around us for free. I’ll be honest, I do, or did, drink bottled water. I buy one every day with lunch, but that was before I knew all of this about being sustainable and saving what doesn’t need to be wasted. I may even start keeping one of my Nalgenes in my locker and filling it during the school day. There are many different ways to approach this bottled water vs. tap water dilemma, but the first step is making the decision to make the change.
Bibliography
  • "Break the Bottled Water Habit | Top Five Ways to Break the Bottled Water Habit." New American Dream Home . N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011. <http://www.newdream.org/water/ways.php>.
  • "How Much Energy Goes Into Making a Bottle of Water?." PhysOrg.com - Science News, Technology, Physics, Nanotechnology, Space Science, Earth Science, Medicine. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011. <http://www.physorg.com/news156506896.html>.
  • "Is Bottled Water Better Than Tap? - ABC News." ABCNews.com: Breaking News, Politics, World News, Good Morning America, Exclusive Interviews - ABC News. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011. <http://abcnews.go.com/2020/Health/story?id=728070&page=3>. 

  • "Pacific Institute - Bottled Water and Energy." Pacific Institute: Research for People and the Planet. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011. <http://www.pacinst.org/topics/